Nestled in the heart of Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania, The Vintage Tavern stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the intersection of classic hospitality and a relaxed atmosphere. Located at 655 Main St, our establishment serves as a gathering place for the local community and visitors alike. We believe that a great dining experience is built upon the foundation of a comfortable environment, attentive service, and a genuine commitment to quality. Whether you are looking for a quiet corner to enjoy a conversation or a lively spot to spend an evening with friends, our doors are open to provide a memorable experience that captures the spirit of the region.
Our philosophy is rooted in the idea that a tavern should be more than just a place to eat and drink; it should be a cornerstone of the neighborhood. We take pride in our surroundings, ensuring that every guest feels at home from the moment they step through our entrance. By focusing on the fundamentals of traditional tavern culture, we strive to create a space where time seems to slow down, allowing our patrons to disconnect from the frantic pace of daily life and reconnect with the simple pleasures of good company and a well-prepared meal.
What Defines Our Experience
A Welcoming Atmosphere: We have carefully curated an interior that balances rustic charm with modern comfort. The design reflects the historical character of the Tobyhanna area, offering a warm and inviting backdrop for any occasion, from casual weekday dinners to celebratory weekend gatherings.
Commitment to Quality: Our team is dedicated to maintaining high standards in every aspect of our service. We focus on sourcing ingredients thoughtfully and preparing each dish with care, ensuring that our menu remains consistent, flavorful, and satisfying for every palate that visits our tables.
Community Connection: Being located on Main Street in Tobyhanna allows us to be an integral part of the local fabric. We value the relationships we build with our guests and strive to contribute positively to the vibrant culture of our town, serving as a reliable hub for residents and travelers passing through the Pocono Mountains.
Attentive Service: We believe that the quality of service is just as important as the quality of the food. Our staff is trained to provide a friendly, professional, and efficient experience, ensuring that your time with us is seamless and enjoyable from start to finish.
The culinary approach at The Vintage Tavern is centered on accessibility and comfort. We understand that our guests often seek familiar flavors executed with precision and care. By focusing on classic techniques and reliable recipes, we aim to provide a dining experience that feels both comforting and refined. Our kitchen team works diligently to ensure that every plate leaving the pass meets our rigorous expectations, reflecting our passion for the craft of cooking and our respect for the ingredients we use.
Beyond the food and drink, it is the people who truly define The Vintage Tavern. We are proud to serve the Tobyhanna community and are grateful for the support of our neighbors who have made us a part of their regular routines. We invite you to join us at 655 Main St to experience the unique blend of tradition and hospitality that we work hard to cultivate every single day. Whether you are a long-time resident or just exploring the beautiful landscape of Pennsylvania, we look forward to welcoming you into our tavern and sharing a moment of genuine connection.
As we continue to grow and evolve, our core mission remains unchanged: to provide a space where quality, comfort, and community converge. We invite you to visit us, pull up a chair, and discover why so many people choose The Vintage Tavern as their preferred local destination. We are constantly striving to improve and refine our offerings, always keeping the needs and preferences of our guests at the forefront of our decisions. Thank you for considering us for your next outing, and we look forward to the opportunity to serve you soon.
Amenities and More
Menus
SNACKS & SHAREABLES
WK Duck Bacon Crustini$12.00
Mozzarella Mezza Luna V$12.00
Pretzel Bites V$8.00
French Fries VE GF$8.00
Witchkraft Style Fries V GF$10.00
Caesar Salad V$9.00
Brussel Spouts VE GF$9.00
Butternut Squash Soup V$9.00
WINGS AND FRIED STRIPS
Vintage Buffalo$12.00
Beer BQ$12.00
Siracha Honey$12.00
Garlic Parm$12.00
Cajun Dry Rub$12.00
SANDWICHES
Witchkraft Cheesesteaks$14.00
Witchkraft Meatball Parm$15.00
WK Pierogi Grilled Cheese V$13.00
Vintage Cheeseburger$15.00
Reuben$13.00
FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICHES
Witchkraft Classic$12.00
Witchkraft Southern Fried$14.00
ENTREES
Venison Strip GF$23.00
Sweet Potato Gnocchi V$19.00
Pork Tender Loin GF$21.00
KIDS
Hot Dog$3.00
Tenders and Fries$8.00
Kids burger and fries$8.00
DESSERTS
Peanut Butter Explosion$12.00
Raspberry Lemon Drop$12.00
Tiramisu$12.00
Photos
Reviews The Vintage Tavern
Michelle Quach
11-05-2026
genuinely one of the best restaurants i’ve been to! the witchkraft sauce on top of the cheesesteak was top tier and i can confidently say that was one of the best cheesesteaks ive ever had. the service was amazing and the atmosphere made it feel very homey!
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Ronald Labes
08-05-2026
This was I and my family's first time and sure will not be our last, I had the pleasure of having Karly serve us, The menu is small as it is for ever good establishment , I love the feel, That I've walked back in time when, I entered the … More
Crystal Adaway
05-02-2026
We feel so lucky to find this gem of a restaurant! They take gluten-free seriously (it's not just an afterthought with a bun), and everything we've tried on their regular & seasonal menus is delicious. Everyone is friendly and helpful, but … More
Theresa Shinn
21-01-2026
Stopped in for lunch while we were in town and so glad we did. We ordered a bunch and it was all delicious! Sriracha honey boneless wings were the table favorite. Karly was our server and she was running the whole place like a boss! We will be back next time we are in town.
Meal type
Lunch
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Doanda Harper
13-01-2026
Been here a few times since they opened always a blast, music is good no head banging, classic rock but at a level that conversation is easy. Food is so good that its reputation is building quickly. The bartenders are at tentative and drinks on spot. Plus they have free trivia which makes it fun competing with your guests. More
Connie Pullan
11-01-2026
We walked in with a big group on Saturday and they were able to accommodate us quickly! The food was great but the stand out of our experience was our server Karly! She was super attentive and did a great job - super patient when we all … More
joseph baude
29-12-2025
We came for our annual holiday trip and decided to change it up a bit this year and we stopped at this adorable tavern. We were welcomed as soon as we walked in and told to sit wherever we would like and other patrons even greeted us with … More
Samantha Eltringham
28-12-2025
We stopped by on Christmas eve, and not only was the service great, but the food was awesome. Our bartender made great food recommendations and she didn’t steer us wrong. We slammed the boneless vintage buffalo wings - they were amazing. We also got the french onion soup which was tasty, and the chicken cheesesteak with everything on it was unreal. We loved the sauce, and the fresh chicken. We definitely plan on swinging by again before we leave to try the famous meatballs!
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Seating type
Bar area, Outdoor patio / terrace, Counter seating
Parking space
Plenty of parking
DJ ReAct (Nick)
24-11-2025
This place doesn’t miss man. I’m not from PA but ffs there is just something magical about the Tavern. The Chef is making miracles in the back and the service up front is killer. They aren’t open late but the vibe is Cheers. There isn’t a single thing on their menu I wouldn’t recommend all of it and I mean all of it was good. If I had to pick one, the cheesesteak. I’m just letting you know that 2025 award isn’t playing around.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Jamie Achberger
19-11-2025
Wow! This place is great! Bacon turkey club and French onion soup was very good!!
I drive by this place all the time and have wanted to stop in. It did not disappoint More
miranda evans
25-10-2025
If i could give infinite stars i would!! Our waitress Michelle was absolutely so friendly and kind, making sure we had everything we needed. The food was unlike anything i’ve ever tasted! The truffle fries had a beautiful distinct taste and were seasoned and fried to perfection! The onion rings were so tasty and crisp. The vodka meatball parm was insanely out of this world !!! The sauce and peppers worked so well together. This place made my bestfriends birthday to the poconos so much better! Definitely will be coming back for the outstanding food and service!
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Bar area, Outdoor patio / terrace
Mig Arias
22-10-2025
Amazing food & best spicy (or non spicy) pickles in town!
I can’t believe I’ve been in the area for three years and only just now stepped into Vintage Tavern. I’ve been missing out!
The food was absolutely incredible.
The service and atmosphere were top-notch:
Chef Tory is doing big things in that kitchen; the flavors were spot on.
Michelle was fantastic. Super attentive, friendly, and kept the vibes high.
A huge shoutout to Chris, who works there and convinced me to come in.
Everyone was so welcoming and friendly. If you’re looking for a great spot with a warm environment and killer food, don't wait three years like I did.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Stephanie Kent
18-10-2025
Stopped here on our way to Camelback. It may be a hole in the wall and in need of some updates, but the food and service and atmosphere were AMAZING. The food is soooo much better than the restaurants in our area (CT). The cheesesteak was … More
Daphna A
15-10-2025
What a fun night! Natalie was the hostess with the mostest and made a perfect black and tan. Gabi hosted trivia night which was so fun, even though we didn’t win. Coming from NYC, this was the ultimate neighborhood bar to hang out at. Nice portions, tasty food, great prices. More
Rapid Runs Transportation
24-09-2025
I stopped into Vintage Tavern to pick up brunch and had a really good experience. From the moment I walked in, the staff was friendly and welcoming, they spoke right away and made me feel comfortable. I’ll be honest, at first I was a little nervous because I didn’t see anyone who looked like me, but that feeling disappeared quickly. Everyone was kind, including the other guests.
They allowed me to take my time looking over the brunch menu, as well as the drink and regular menus, which I appreciated. I ordered two orders of hash browns, beer-battered catfish with French fries, French toast (they forgot the berries, but it wasn’t a big deal), Cajun cauliflower bites, an arugula salad, and their Philly cheesesteak made by their chef who’s from Philly.
Even though the berries were missing, they threw in pancakes, so I wasn’t upset at all. Everything was hot, highly flavorful, and outrageously delicious especially for takeout. The catfish was perfectly battered, the Cajun cauliflower was a pleasant surprise, and the cheesesteak was legit!
Overall, great food, friendly staff, and a welcoming vibe. I’d definitely order from them anytime we are in the poconos!
Meal type
Brunch
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Witchkraft Cheesesteaks, Pretzel Bites, Full Bar
Paulette
22-09-2025
Great food and service!
We had two appetizers, two sandwiches, and three drinks. The spinach artichoke bites and onion rings were both delicious—especially the onion rings, which were … More
Ryan
19-09-2025
Great food ! Good service ! Relaxing atmosphere.
Chris did an amazing job, he made sure to go above and beyond for us. Very … More
George Palickar
10-08-2025
We really enjoyed this classic, hometown inn and tavern! We picked it just because we were never there, and it was on the way home from a trip in the Poconos. Very pleasantly surprised! The beer was cold, good selection, and the food was spot on. They specialize in sandwiches, and I had to say we enjoyed our burgers thoroughly! Great tunes too! We will certainly be back to check out some other items. Loved the vintage shuffleboard table too! They look like they have a nice patio setup too so we will be back when the weather is nice.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Special events
No special event
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Poundcake Says
09-08-2025
I came here twice during my stay in Tobyhanna because I HAD to have another burger and another wiked pickletini. The blend on that patty is SUPERB. I also bought some pickles to bring home because they are so delicious. The second visit was … More
Hannah Rogers
20-07-2025
Hubby and I came here and we had the entire dining room to ourselves. There's a reason their sauce is called Witchkraft. I had the classic chicken sandwich and he had wings. The fries are massive so we split a tray. No notes. More
Reviews The Vintage Tavern